AWS RDS to EDB Migration Guide: Boost PostgreSQL Scalability

Discover key tools and steps for effective cloud database migration

Why Migrate from AWS RDS to EDB?

Explore the benefits of cloud database migration

There are several advantages to migrating from AWS RDS to EnterpriseDB (EDB), namely cost savings, flexibility, performance, and support:

Cost Savings

While AWS RDS operates on a usage-based pricing structure, EDB offers a subscription-based pricing model. This model eliminates the per-processor licensing fees of proprietary databases, leading to long-term savings, especially for large-scale operations. Moreover, EDB’s pricing structure can reduce total cost of ownership (TCO), allowing easier budget management. EDB also minimizes administrative overhead through automated maintenance and resource management.

Deployment and Customization Flexibility

EDB supports more database options and versions than AWS RDS. Its open source nature also allows more customization options, such as defining custom data types and integrating third-party tools. Furthermore, EDB's ability to deploy across hybrid and multi-cloud environments enhances organizational agility, leveraging the cloud without vendor lock-in.

Better Performance

EDB Postgres® AI Cloud Service uses a proprietary storage architecture optimized for resilience and scalability across availability zones. Furthermore, EDB can achieve higher availability than RDS, promising up to 99.995% uptime compared to RDS’s 99.95% SLA.

Ongoing Support

EDB users enjoy comprehensive support services, including technical guidance during migration, ongoing system maintenance, and a focus on optimizing database performance. Organizations can ensure that mission-critical workloads remain uninterrupted and efficient with support from EDB experts.

Understanding AWS RDS vs. EDB

Compare cloud databases before migrating

AWS RDS and EDB differ significantly in terms of scalability and cost. Here’s a breakdown.

Scalability

AWS RDS scalability

AWS RDS offers vertical and horizontal scalability options.

Vertical scaling: This involves increasing resources such as CPU and memory for individual RDS instances. It allows immediate capacity upgrades with a few clicks on the AWS Management Console. AWS RDS supports various instance types optimized for different workloads, allowing users to choose a configuration that meets their needs.

Horizontal scaling: This entails the addition of more database instances. RDS can scale out by deploying read replicas (read-only copies of the primary database), improving read-heavy workloads. It also supports RDS Proxy, which helps manage numerous database connections, enhancing performance and scalability.

AWS RDS can handle increased data volume and user load through features such as Multi-AZ deployments for high availability and auto-scaling capabilities, which adjust resources dynamically based on current workloads.

EDB scalability

EDB focuses on robust scalability options through its managed PostgreSQL service.

Horizontal scaling: EDB also supports horizontal scaling by clustering databases, adding nodes to accommodate greater loads. This approach enhances performance for complex queries and large databases. EDB emphasizes flexibility, allowing users to customize their clusters and configurations based on specific operational requirements.

The open source nature of PostgreSQL permits extensive customization and adaptability for varied workloads, without the constraints typical of proprietary systems.

Cost Considerations

AWS RDS cost structure

AWS RDS employs a usage-based pricing model in which customers pay based on the resources they consume:

On-demand instances: Users pay per second for the compute capacity required, which offers flexibility but can lead to unpredictable costs, depending on usage patterns and peak times.

Reserved instances: Reserved instances allow organizations to reserve capacity for one to three years with various payment options (no up-front, partial up-front, all up-front).

Storage and data transfer costs: Costs also accrue from data transfer, stored backups, and provisioned input/output operations per second (IOPS), which can add to the overall expenditure.

EDB cost structure

EDB’s pricing is predominantly subscription-based, differing considerably from AWS RDS’s model:

Subscription pricing: EDB offers fixed-rate subscription plans that cover the software, support, and resources needed to operate. This model provides more predictable monthly costs compared to the usage-based model of AWS RDS, making budgeting for database expenses more straightforward.

Cost efficiency: This pricing structure can lead to lower TCO, especially for organizations utilizing substantial computational resources, as it eliminates the per-processor licensing fees typically found in proprietary systems.

Initial costs: While EDB may have higher up-front licensing fees compared to the cost-free entry point of AWS RDS, this can lead to savings for larger deployments, particularly given the potential for lower operational costs over time.

AWS to EDB Migration: A Step-by-Step Guide

Ensure efficient cloud database migration in six steps

A comprehensive migration strategy from AWS RDS to EDB involves multiple steps to ensure that the transition is seamless and meets organizational objectives.

Step 1: Assessment and Planning

  • Inventory analysis: Identify all databases, schemas, and functionalities used in AWS RDS. Assess the specific RDS instance types, sizes, and configurations currently used.
  • Data volume assessment: Determine the volume of data stored in the current AWS RDS instance, analyzing growth rates and expected future needs.
  • Dependency mapping: Evaluate application dependencies linked to RDS (e.g., app code, integrations, third-party tools).
  • Migration goals definition: Clearly outline the migration objectives, including cost reduction, enhanced performance, and the flexibility to scale effectively.
  • Risk identification: Identify potential risks and challenges involved in migration, including data loss, downtime, and compatibility issues.

Step 2: Schema and Data Migration

  • Schema assessment: Analyze the schema in AWS RDS and prepare it for migration by ensuring compatibility with EDB standards. Tools such as EDB’s Migration Portal can assist in assessing the compatibility of database schemas with EDB Postgres Advanced Server.
  • Data migration tools: Utilize tools such as EDB’s Migration Toolkit and Replication Server to migrate data from RDS to EDB Postgres Advanced Server. These tools facilitate snapshot-based or continuous data migration techniques.
  • Data transformation: Modify data types and SQL syntax to ensure compatibility with EDB. Conduct pre-migration data-cleansing to identify and rectify discrepancies or redundant data.
  • Data transfer: Perform the actual data migration using selected tools while ensuring minimal services interruption. Consider a phased migration approach to reduce risks associated with downtime.

Step 3: Application Migration

  • Code adaptation: Review and modify application code to accommodate EDB’s specific functionalities and conventions. This may require changes in database connectivity and query syntax.
  • Testing connectivity: Ensure that all application interfaces are properly connected to the new EDB database and function as expected. Use EDB-compatible drivers and connectors for smooth integration.
  • Compatibility checks: Validate that the application can effectively manage data transactions, leveraging EDB-specific features where necessary.

Step 4: Testing and Validation

  • Post-migration testing: Conduct functional and performance testing to ensure that all applications interact correctly with the EDB database. Include user acceptance testing (UAT) to get feedback from stakeholders and identify any issues.
  • Cross-check data integrity: Utilize automated testing tools to validate that migrated data matches the original data sets and maintains integrity.

Step 5: EDB Deployment Options

  • Kubernetes operators: For a containerized environment, use the EDB Postgres for Kubernetes operators to manage workloads effectively. This option provides high availability and scalability through native streaming replication.
  • On-premises deployment: Consider on-prem deployments for organizations requiring greater control over their database environment. This option allows high customization and adherence to internal policies.
  • Cloud deployments: Explore public cloud options, where EDB services such as EDB Postgres AI Cloud Service provide fully managed solutions.
  • Hybrid and private cloud: Implement hybrid deployments that leverage on-prem and cloud capabilities to optimize performance while maintaining compliance requirements.

Step 6: Deployment and Optimization

  • Go-live preparation: Establish a detailed cutover plan to transition from AWS RDS to EDB with minimal disruption. Include timelines outlining when systems should come online and when legacy systems will be retired.
  • Monitoring and performance optimization: Post-migration, employ tools such as EDB Postgres Enterprise Manager for ongoing performance monitoring and optimization. Set up alerts for performance thresholds and implement metrics monitoring for resource consumption.
  • Continuous improvement: Gather user feedback to enhance database configurations and application performances continuously. Regularly audit systems for compliance and integrity.

Tools and Strategies for Efficient Cloud Database Migration

Check out EDB’s options for streamlining the move from AWS RDS

Migrating from AWS RDS to EDB involves careful planning and use of specialized tools and strategies to ensure a smooth transition.

Recommended Tools for Migration

pgAdmin

pgAdmin is one of the most prominent management tools available for EDB. Its features and benefits are:

Database management: pgAdmin offers a comprehensive interface for database administration, making it easier for users to manage EDB Postgres instances. It supports user management, data browsing, and configuration adjustments.

Query tool: The integrated query tool in pgAdmin allows users to execute SQL queries and view their results in real time, facilitating interaction with the migrated database. This tool supports functionalities such as syntax highlighting and data visualization, enhancing the user experience.

Performance monitoring: pgAdmin includes performance-monitoring features, enabling users to track database performance metrics, spot bottlenecks, and optimize queries accordingly. It aids in identifying resources that could need scaling.

User-friendly interface: The intuitive graphical user interface (GUI) simplifies complex tasks, making it accessible for users with varying levels of technical expertise. This is particularly beneficial in a migration context, as it reduces the learning curve associated with new tools.

Migration Toolkit

EDB also provides the Migration Toolkit. Its features and benefits include:

Data migration: The Migration Toolkit facilitates online and offline data migrations from AWS RDS to EDB. It supports snapshot-based migrations, which ensure minimal downtime during the transition process.

Granular control: Users can specify detailed migration options, including batch size, column data type conversions, and row filtering based on specific criteria, providing flexibility for complex migration scenarios.

Schema conversion: The tool simplifies the migration of schema definitions, ensuring compatibility with EDB’s standards. This conversion includes adjusting data types and modifying SQL syntax for seamless integration.

Testing capabilities: The Migration Toolkit allows testing of migrations during the process, enabling users to validate data integrity and ensure that the migration meets predefined specifications before full deployment.

Documentation support: Comprehensive logs and reports are generated during the migration process, providing insights into successes and challenges, which can be crucial for future migrations or audits.

Strategies for Effective Migration

Beyond the tools mentioned, the following strategies can further improve the migration process:

Detailed planning

Evaluate the AWS RDS setup to gather vital information regarding database size, usage patterns, and integrations. Set specific migration goals that align with the organization’s overarching business objectives, such as cost savings or performance improvements.

Phased migration approach

Consider breaking the migration into manageable phases, migrating components incrementally, and validating each segment before proceeding. This technique minimizes risks and allows troubleshooting without impacting the entire system.

Stakeholder communication

Keep relevant stakeholders informed about the migration progress and encourage feedback to address any concerns that arise throughout the process.

Post-migration review and optimization

After migration, continually monitor database performance to identify inefficiencies or areas for improvement. Utilize EDB’s built-in monitoring tools for ongoing optimization. Training sessions on using pgAdmin and other EDB tools should be provided to involve staff in the new environment and enhance their proficiency in daily operations.

Best Practices After Cloud Database Migration

Get tips on database optimization after AWS RDS to EDB migration

To ensure a successful transition from AWS RDS to PostgreSQL and maintain ongoing database health, it is essential to incorporate best practices across several key areas, including performance tuning, monitoring, backup and recovery, high availability, security, and updates.

Performance Tuning

  • Hardware configuration: Ensure that adequate CPU, RAM, and disk resources are tailored to your workload.
  • PostgreSQL configuration: Adjust key configuration parameters based on your specific workload.
  • max_connections: Set according to the expected number of concurrent users.
  • shared_buffers: Allocate up to 25% of total system RAM for caching data.
  • maintenance_work_mem: Increase for maintenance operations, such as indexing, to enhance performance.
  • WAL tuning: Optimize write-ahead logging (WAL) settings to reduce performance overhead during write operations. Consider parameters such as checkpoint_timeout and max_wal_size to balance data integrity and performance.
  • Indexing: Create appropriate indexes on frequently queried columns to speed up data retrieval while being mindful of the overhead.
  • Vacuuming: Regularly use the VACUUM command to reclaim storage by removing obsolete records. Configure autovacuum to run automatically, based on your database’s activity.

Regular Monitoring

  • pgAdmin: This provides graphical monitoring and management of PostgreSQL databases, including server activity and performance metrics.
  • pgBadger: This analyzes PostgreSQL log files to highlight slow queries and performance bottlenecks.
  • Prometheus or Zabbix: This is used for comprehensive performance metrics and alerting capabilities.

Backup and Recovery

  • Logical backups: Use pg_dump for logical backups of your databases. This allows easier migrations and robust recovery options.
  • Physical backups: Utilize pg_basebackup for full data directory backups, which can be critical during disaster recovery scenarios.
  • Incremental backups: Implement incremental backups to reduce backup times and storage requirements. This enables backups to include only changes from the last backup.
  • Regular testing: Regularly test your backup restoration process to ensure that backups can be restored quickly and accurately during data loss. This should be part of your routine maintenance.
  • WAL archiving: Implement continuous archiving of WAL files for point-in-time recovery (PITR), allowing the database to be restored to any specific point in time.

High Availability

  • Read replicas: Create read replicas to offload read traffic from the primary instance, improving performance and availability. This setup can also allow failover during primary instance outages.
  • Streaming replication: Use PostgreSQL’s built-in feature to continuously replicate data from primary to standby servers, ensuring that the standby is always up to date.
  • Failover solutions: Implement automated failover processes using tools such as Pgpool or Patroni, which facilitate seamless transitions to standby servers in the event of a failure.

Security

  • Access control: Utilize roles and permissions to fine-tune user access to sensitive data. Follow the principle of least privilege to minimize risks.
  • Transport security: Ensure that all data transmissions between the client and server are encrypted using Transport Layer Security (TLS) to protect against eavesdropping.
  • Database security measures: Enforce row-level security policies, monitor access logs, and utilize firewalls to control incoming and outgoing traffic.

Updates

  • Scheduled updates: Plan routine major and minor version updates. Regular upgrades enhance security and provide new features and performance improvements.
  • Auto Minor Version upgrades: Consider enabling the Auto Minor Version upgrade feature where supported in cloud environments, to ensure that your PostgreSQL instances benefit from immediate updates without manual intervention.
  • Testing updates: Before applying updates, thoroughly test new versions in a staging environment to identify potential issues and ensure compatibility with existing applications and workloads.

EDB Solutions for Cloud Database Migration

Discover EDB’s tools and services for enhancing the migration experience

EDB provides robust solutions for migrating databases to PostgreSQL, allowing organizations to efficiently transition from legacy systems while minimizing disruption.​ These solutions include specialized migration tools, comprehensive support services, and expert consultation.

Migration Tools

  • Migration Toolkit: This command-line tool facilitates various database migration scenarios, focusing on snapshot-type data migrations. It offers extensive command options to customize how source information is loaded into the target database.
  • Migration Portal: A free online service that assesses the compatibility of Oracle database schemas with EDB Postgres Advanced Server. Users can upload a SQL-formatted DDL file and receive a comprehensive compatibility report and necessary modifications.
  • Replication Server: This application allows robust data replication from non-PostgreSQL databases (including Oracle) to PostgreSQL in single-master mode. It supports change data capture (CDC) for real-time data migration, helpful in environments where downtime must be minimized.
  • EDB Postgres Advanced Server: Enhanced with built-in compatibility for Oracle databases, this server simplifies migration by supporting Oracle-specific data types, SQL extensions, and PL/SQL, reducing the need for extensive code modifications.

Support Services

  • Migration Assessment Service: This service provides a detailed analysis of the existing database, evaluating the complexity of the migration and the time required for it.
  • Database testing and validation: EDB offers services to validate the integrity and performance of the migrated database. This includes functional and performance testing to ensure that all systems operate as expected after migration.
  • Post-migration support: After migration, EDB provides ongoing support to help organizations optimize their new PostgreSQL environments. This includes assistance with performance-tuning and resolving any post-migration issues.

Expert Consultation

  • Technical experts: EDB’s database experts guide the migration process, offering insights and strategies tailored to the organization’s needs. This includes advising on best practices for installing, configuring, and optimizing PostgreSQL environments.
  • Tailored migration strategies: The consultation process often involves customizing migration plans that align with an organization’s operational goals, ensuring minimal disruption during the transition.
  • Training and workshops: EDB provides training programs for development and DBA teams, equipping them with the knowledge and skills to effectively manage the new PostgreSQL environment post-migration.

Cloud Database Migration: Content and Resources

Get additional insights and advice for your AWS RDS to EDB migration

What are the five most common challenges first-timers face when moving to PostgreSQL in the cloud, and how are they addressed?


How is fast-food giant McDonald’s comparable to Amazon RDS and Amazon Aurora for Postgres?


Leaving your legacy database at last? Use this comprehensive guide to let EDB’s seasoned experts guide your move to PostgreSQL in the cloud.


Simplify Cloud Database Migration with EDB

AWS RDS to EDB migration is more efficient with EDB’s tools and support

Prepare and execute a smooth, fault-free migration with EDB’s comprehensive suite of services. Opt for offline or online migration and test migration scenarios, customize your transfer based on organizational needs, and more, all with the help of EDB’s seasoned experts.

What are the benefits of migrating from AWS RDS to EDB? chevron_right

Migrating from AWS RDS to EDB offers several benefits, including significant cost savings due to reduced total cost of ownership and improved performance.​ EDB provides greater flexibility in deployment options and customizations, allowing organizations to tailor their database configurations to meet specific workload requirements. Additionally, EDB’s advanced tools and support facilitate easier management and scalability.

What tools are available for migrating from AWS RDS to EDB? chevron_right

Several effective tools can be utilized to migrate from AWS RDS to EDB, including AWS Database Migration Service (DMS), which simplifies the process of migrating data by enabling continuous data replication with minimal downtime.​ Additionally, the EDB Migration Toolkit offers command-line utilities for executing various migration scenarios, and the Migration Portal allows assessment of database schema compatibility with EDB Postgres Advanced Server. EDB’s Replication Server supports real-time data migration using change data capture (CDC), ensuring a seamless transition while enhancing overall operational efficiency.

How do I plan a successful migration from AWS RDS to EDB? chevron_right

To plan a successful migration from AWS RDS to EDB, assess your current database schema and identify any changes needed to adapt to EDB Postgres compatibility. Next, leverage automated migration tools such as EDB Replication Server to facilitate data transfer. It is also essential to carefully migrate application logic, ensuring compatibility with any nonstandard features. Finally, conduct thorough testing post-migration to validate performance, availability, and data integrity.

What are the cost implications of migrating to EDB? chevron_right

There are key differences in pricing models for storage and performance.​ For instance, AWS RDS charges higher rates for provisioned IOPS. Additionally, organizations may face vendor lock-in expenses and data migration complexities, which can incur both direct costs and potential downtimes during the transition period. Thus, careful evaluation of total cost ownership is crucial to avoid overspending during and after migration.

There are also data transfer costs from AWS related to sending data over from RDS to EDB. These will depend on the transfer speeds, amount of data, and other factors.

What are EDB’s advantages over AWS RDS in terms of flexibility? chevron_right

Unlike AWS RDS, which has limitations on custom extensions and configurations, EDB allows users to integrate open source and proprietary extensions, empowering organizations to tailor their databases to specific business needs. Additionally, EDB’s architecture facilitates advanced features such as enhanced security, performance tuning, and scalability options, enabling organizations to customize deployments to match unique workloads and compliance requirements more effectively than would the more rigid AWS RDS.

How can EDB assist with the migration process? chevron_right

EDB offers a comprehensive suite of support and tools for migration, facilitating seamless transitions from various database systems.​ Key tools include the Migration Toolkit, which provides granular control over the migration process, and the Migration Portal, which assesses schema compatibility with EDB Postgres. Additionally, EDB offers professional services to assist in planning and executing migrations, ensuring that organizations can efficiently address specific migration challenges while minimizing downtime.